Does the Education Minister not know that cats are banned from HDB flats?

8964

Education Minister Ong Ye Kung was greeted with a “delightful surprise” as he went on walkabouts in Sembawang GRC last week. The Minister was charmed by a letter one of the families living in a block left him – the Tan family apologised to the Minister for not being home to receive him and added that their cat is unable to open the door for him. They appended a photo of their cat to the letter.

Even though no one's home, once in a while there's a delightful surprise – like this warm note from the Tan family. The…

Posted by Ong Ye Kung on Thursday, 3 August 2017

The Minister invited the family to the Gambas National Day Carnival, commenting on his Facebook page that “the smallest member (the cat) looks like a charmer too!”

But, wait – does Mr Ong know that it’s technically illegal to keep cats in HDB flats? Or did he purposefully ignore the rigid housing rules?

Source: HDB website

It’s not even like the cat ban is a little-known law that’s hardly enforced. Just this year, two cases made headlines where Housing Development Board (HDB) charged flat residents for keeping cats and threatened to evict the cats.

This letter went viral in January this year, when HDB threatened to evict a cat from a HDB flat and expressly and explicitly stated that the keeping of cats is “strictly prohibited.”

In responding to the viral circulation of this letter, Cat Welfare Society said that such rules make people angry and panicked.

This letter has gone viral and has been making the rounds on social media. It shows exactly WHY HDB should stop charging…

Posted by Cat Welfare Society on Saturday, 7 January 2017

In the second, more bizarre incident that occurred in April this year, a woman – Ms Serene Tong – was asked to evict her cats because her neighbours had a problem with Ms Tong making too much noise while greeting her 3 cats and because she allegedly talked to her cats loudly, sang to them and slams her door very loudly.

Ms Tong alleged that her neighbour was only using her cats to get to her. She said on Facebook:

Ms Tong was given just one month to rehome her cats. She had had two of them for 12 years and the last for 6 years. All cats were sterilised and kept indoors.

It's happened again. A responsible owner is being targeted by neighbours and HDB has taken action by asking her to…

Posted by Cat Welfare Society on Tuesday, 18 April 2017

The Cat Welfare Society also urged concerned readers to write to Deputy Prime Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam, highlighting Ms Tong and her cats plight?

With two such viral cases occurring just this year, it’s a little unbelievable to think that the Education Minister might not be educated about the cat ban.

Or is it too far-fetched to think that his Facebook post is a signal that HDB will relax pet rules in Singapore? What do you think?

 

Get the latest news, opinions and commentaries. Available on Android  

38 comments

  1. Whats wrong with you!? Trying to stir shit again? Omg post something that is good for the society and not something that is gona cause more problems…. we cat lovers dont like this kinda posts!

  2. Irene Hoe says:

    Instead of insulting one another, how about those who would like to see cats permitted in HDB flats starting a petition. Every MP has an email address listed online. If enough people write to enough MPs, perhaps something more constructive can come of this/

  3. Went to a session with the MP to raise the issue of animal abuse in the neighborhood. Met the volunteers who simply told me “not national policy”.

    They could make up and change laws overnight, but for pet ownership laws like these, they drag their feet with “we have to discuss and debate”, preferring to keep archaic law based on outdated information.

  4. We have so many rules and regulations that it is no wonder we often inadvertently offend. I believe the authorities could exercise common sense and inject some humanity into their decisions.

  5. HDB refuses to over turn their pointless and senseless ruling. The reasons given in the HDB website are rubbish for the ban.
    Dogs or cats, if properly taken care of, trained and good hygiene is practiced, does not pose a problem to be kept in a HDB flat.

    But many MPs overlook this because they don’t wish to enforce it unless there is a complaint. So don’t crucify the minister as he’s actually being kind enough to close one eye and make it a humorous situation.

    People these days are too much. If someone allows, kena crucify. Don’t allow, kena crucify.

    Live and let live, people.

  6. The nature of Cat is ……. ?

    The nature of Dog is Faithful and loyal to the owner.

    So you be your own judge.

    Loyalty Dogs or ….. Cat that ….. rats catchers ?

    LolHahahaOhm

  7. Lim LG says:

    HDB RULE : “CATS CAN SHED ITS FUR”??

    OTHER ANIMALS LIKE DOGS AND BIRDS ALSO HV FUR. AND HDB ALLOWS RESIDENTS TO KEEP THEM IN HDB FLATS, WHY NOT CATS?? SO ILLOGICAL!!

    LET ME TELL YOU WHO IS AGAINST IT?

    IT WAS THE ROTTON LEADER LHL WHO SAID “CATS WOULD GO TO NEIGHBORS AND DISTURB THEM.”
    THIS SHOWS HE ISN’T A PET LOVER, NOT KIND HEARTED LEADER.

  8. BABA SANI says:

    POVERTY IS NOT CURSE OR A CROSS TO CARRY TILL YOUR LAST DAY ON EARTH. You can chose to have a good and wealthy life today, some wealthy people you see today have skeletons behind their wealth. BABA SANI is here to help get your financial problems solve within 7days. Don’t let poverty take over you.. inbox BABA SANI now, or write me on my email babasanitemple@gmail.com. for all your spiritual problems, you want to
    live in realm of wealth….more info inbox me no.
    Here are some problems i help…..
    HIV/Aids….
    Bareness…
    Helping of students……..
    giving people magic……
    treating of madness………
    traveling issues……
    eyes problems………
    lotto numbers ……..
    infertility….
    Yahoo plus/magic finger……
    love ring and marriage issues……
    Quick Money,wallet doubler… etc.
    for all spiritual problems inbox BABA SANI now and Email babasanitemple@hmail.com
    For serious minded people, Don’t write me if your not serious for your own sake. Be warned.

  9. Mohd Ihsan says:

    Like this is kpkb, later he complaint you all say he no heart..the cat cause problem? No right? So whats the big fucking deal? Many singaporeans have cats at home, hdb can easily find alot of them just by going through the cat groups on facebook..seriously..admins on this pages needs to get a good knocking on the head by their moms

    1. Dogs are leashed in public and owners required to pick up after their dogs. To equate ruling for cats the same to dogs is illogical and misguided to put it kindly.

Comments are closed.