Xiaxue calls Minister K. Shanmugam out for playing identity politics on Facebook


By Phyllis Lee

On Thursday evening (Sept 14), Minister of Home Affairs and Law K. Shanmugam posted a photo of President Halimah Yacob with Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong and Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon on Facebook.

He captioned the photo: “Malay President, Chinese Prime Minister and Indian Chief Justice. Representation of Singapore.”

In response to this, Singaporean blogger Xiaxue wrote an 814-word long post accusing him, as well as the public, of playing identity politics on Friday (Sept 15).

She said: “Don’t play identity politics because it’s a slippery slope that never ends. You will end up dividing the nation as collectivism takes over, separating people by into divisive groups competing with each other for so called equality – when people are supposed to be treated as individuals.”

The well-known PAP supporter continued by pointing out the lack of representation for the female, agonist, atheist, LGBT, overweight, disabled, midget and less-educated communities in the Cabinet.

Moving on to the general public, she cited a popular tweet she saw, which said that only the Chinese were angry with the elections results, followed by a sarcastic “I wonder why”.

“We are all Singaporeans that didn’t get to vote, it’s natural we are upset. Please don’t make this a race thing. But hey this is an example of what identity politics do; divide people. You are Chinese? You are not part of my group,” she posted.

Xiaxue lamented that it’s a shame that Mdm Halimah isn’t recognised for her personal experience and achievements, but instead for her race and gender.

She concluded:
“At least if Singaporeans elected her we can say that as a nation we believed that a woman can do what is traditionally a man’s job and perhaps there is a little something to be proud of there, condescending as it is. But we weren’t even given that chance.
So continue to call her “Malay President” I suppose – by all means emphasize the fact that her race is why she got elected (is that the right word since there is no election), not by democratic choice for all her merits.
All of you know I’m a staunch PAP supporter. But I’m feeling pretty disillusioned tbh.”

Get the latest news, opinions and commentaries. Available on Android  


  1. Facebook Profile photo
    Kah Howe Lee ( User Karma: 0 ) says:

    Since you want a chance to elect her and now that she is the President, isn’t the outcome the same?

    Unless the current result is not what you u want but yet that contradicts with your statement that you want a chance to elect her.

    Blended brain.

  2. Facebook Profile photo
    rlsh2017 ( User Karma: 0 ) says:

    It’s time to get the Pest Terminator to rid these White Termites. They chew on your flesh, now flesh more, they chew on bones.

    These termites are trying to rid Seniors by stressing them to their death bed with Cashless Society with aim to reduce the huge subsidies on these seniors

  3. Jeenee Ng says:

    If not now she has to declare TAX for her gifts receiving from her sponsors, u think she dares to backstab her beloved master? Remember her campaign slogan for her master? “Riding with the lightning”, now she kena strikes by lightning… Lol

  4. Facebook Profile photo
    William Lim ( User Karma: 0 ) says:

    can’t trust an old ugly prostitute ranting on heat. talk against group/race politics, then complaint that other groups are not included? disillusioned? not surprised. cpf 55 to cpf 65.

  5. Edwin Kwan says:

    I kinda agree with XY. I am sure those ministers, scholars, etc who think they are intellectually superior, would have analysed the matter till death and arrived at outcomes, amongst many, similar to XY. I wonder why the government is willing to forego votes lost at the next GE. To gain or sustain what agenda ?

  6. Ng Alfred says:

    Now we have a Malay President..a Chinese Prime Minister…an Indian Deputy Prime Minister. .an
    Indian Chief Justice…why no Sikh minister…why no Eurasian minister…why no baba minister…why no Indian Muslim minister…and so on and on…it will never end…if you want a race game…

  7. I’m afraid that even with all the true born singaporeans binding together it’s too little too late. The population ponzi has succeeded and achieved critical mass to displace the voice of real singaporeans

  8. Chris Lim says:

    Fully agree. I have always been a 100% PAP supporter. Now, I am thinking otherwise. So many scholars in the entire cabinet, why did they all let this happen!

  9. During LKY days he avoided touching on topic that involves race or religion & for 50 years we have been living together as Singaporean & I “was” proud being one too.
    Barely just 2 and a half year after his death …. I don’t know why the men in white keep talking & touching on the topic about race what is their real intentions & purpose ?

    1. PK Ang says:

      LKY, avoided talking about race n religion ? are you joking ? If what you say is true, how did he promoted minorities rights n Malay rights ?

      Please follow all his videos where he talked about Races n Religious issue head on..

  10. Whole process is a mockery! From the time from Nair to Halimah….the existence of PE committee itself clearly is an artificial block to any suitable non-PAP candidates. If Singaporeans still do not realized that we being ‘cowed’ by these ‘?’ public leaders to protect their own bases of power…..say what you wish or don’t, Xiaxue, the joke is on the stupidity of Singaporeans – our freedom is worse than Hong Kong citzens. You cannot even choose a President!

    1. Jairus Lau says:

      So, we are looking at the next Olympics gold coming from either a Malay or an Indian athlete or swimmer. Also, we divide the Chinese into the various dialects and they rotate for President and Prime Minister. Say, what about companies’ CEOs?!?!

  11. Albert Tan says:

    And this coming from none other than the Law Minister himself.

    Is he MAD? Stoking the flames of racism.

    Will hold him responsible n those eunuchs in the PAP trying to divide the simple folks, just to stay in power. We are one united people regardless of race religion or creed.

    Never allow evil politicians to sow dissension amongst the races. I count my Malay n Indian brothers and sisters as one big harmonious family.

    Evil politicians in the PAP playing the racial card have no place in our society. We need to be alert and call them out for who they are n VOTE THEM ALL OUT THIS COMING 2020GE

    Personally, evil politicians playing the racial card I would rate them in the same category as murderers and child rapists.

    1. David Ong says:

      Actually we don’t have to be pro-white or pro-blue as long as we live by right conscious and common sense understanding. Singapore desperately needs that principle.

  12. PAP always uses d fear tactic to scare us. Now they use d race card. I support yoyr call for d goverment to accept all of us as Singaporeans..n not as Chinese. Malay Indians etc.

    1. Jairus Lau says:

      The seniors will remember the debate with respect to our I/C : either delete Race and replace with Nationality – Singapore, or, have both. Because we are proud of both, Nationality and Race. Today, some of us will shy away from presenting our I/Cs, not knowing who we are.

Comments are closed.