‘You cut the fruit for me’: SG parents discuss whether kids should be allowed to boss helpers around

Yoko Nicole Villarin
|
4 m read
‘You cut the fruit for me’: SG parents discuss whether kids should be allowed to boss helpers around
Photo: Magnific/jcomp (for illustration purposes only)

Domestic helper carrying a toddler

SINGAPORE: A man has sparked an online discussion after asking “Singaporean parents of toddlers and young children whether they allow their kids to boss their domestic helpers around.”

In a post on the r/askSingapore forum on Sunday (Nov 15), he shared an incident involving one of his wife's relatives that prompted him to ask the question.

Over a recent dinner, the relative shared a story about his 3-year-old son that he found “cute.” Apparently, the little boy had told their helper, who had only been working for the family for three months, to cut some fruit for him. It was also the family's first time hiring a domestic helper.

“His 3-year-old son had apparently told their helper—who's only three months into the job, with this being the family's first time hiring a helper—’Kakak, you cut the fruit for me.’ The way he mimicked his son sounded noticeably bossy, yet he found it hilarious, and the grandparents laughed along about how ‘smart’ the boy was.”

The man said he and his wife talked about it afterwards, and she felt the exact same way as he did. 

“We don't hire a full-time helper, though we do have a part-time helper come in weekly. We've always taught our kids to treat her with respect as an auntie and never boss her around—something we model ourselves, too.” 

“Even if we had a live-in helper, we'd never allow our children to talk to her or any cleaner that way. Maybe it's just me, but I didn't find the story funny at all.”

‘They'll grow up to be brats if not taught what respect is’

In the comments, many Singaporean Redditors suggested the toddler was likely copying the adults around him.

One user explained, “I see this less as the kid bossing the maid around and more as mimicking the parents' behaviours. My kid does the exact same thing with some of his interactions— we changed our ways as soon as we noticed, and he changed right along with us. I've seen this happen with my mom and my sister as well—it escalated into my sister hitting the maid for making mistakes, while my mom only stuck to verbal. Kids will escalate because it's logical and they don't know boundaries. So it's very important to be careful of what you teach your kids, especially on how you act around them.”

Another commented, “I absolutely DETEST when I see/hear kids being bossy to the helper, or refusing to do what the helper asks. Parents need to raise their kids better.”

A third shared, “My kids adore my helper and have been taught to speak to her with respect. If I ever overhear them missing out their Ps and Qs, they are audibly reminded. If they are ever rude to my helper, they are told off. That’s the way it’s been since they were born, and it’ll continue that way.”

A fourth added, “As a parent with a helper myself, when I hear my kids ‘demanding’ something, I'll correct them to say 'please' and 'thank you' and ask nicely. They'll grow up to be brats if not taught what respect is.”

Not everyone, however, felt that parents should be held entirely responsible for their children's behaviour. One Redditor pointed out that children could also pick up habits from school and their surroundings, while some behaviours might simply be part of growing up.

Newsletter

Get updates straight to your inbox

“After becoming a parent, I disagree. In the first place, parents aren't the only influence; my kid picks up all sorts of things from school. Second is that if you think kids are inherently angels and need to be taught how to be rude or hit people, etc., hahaha yeah no. Pick any 1yo baby, see whether they scream when they get upset or want something. Bossing someone around is a more sophisticated extension of that.”

“Third is that as kids grow up, they get more confident and assertive. That can spill over into bossiness towards everyone. Fourth, some of this also comes from kids' inherent nature to push boundaries. Basically, there are a multitude of possible reasons for the incident. I'd raise eyebrows mainly if this story was being told right in front of the kid, if the tone was very bad (eg bossy / assertive versus downright rude), or it's clear the parent isn't correcting the behaviour.”/TISG

Read also: SG employer torn over raising maid's salary from S$650 to S$850 as her husband battles cancer